• Home
  • Security Consultant
  • Expert Witness
  • Articles
  • Podcast
  • Media Interviews
  • Contact

Crime Doctor

Making Places Safe

Apartment Premises Liability for Personal Injury Caused by Criminal Acts

January 30, 2023 Chris McGoey

Apartment premises liability litigation appears to be a growth industry.

  • Multi-million dollar lawsuits against landlords are not unusual.
  • What steps can a property owner take to minimize the liability risk?
apartment premises liability

Advertisement by Lawfirm Seeking Clients

Apartment Premises Liability: For Criminal Acts of Others

It’s no secret that victims of violent crime can sue a landlord or property manager for injuries received during a criminal assault on apartment premises. The legal theory is called premises liability. The demand for monetary damages can go into the millions for alleged physical and psychological injuries.

In recent years, jury awards have been so lucrative that the American Trial Lawyers Association produces an annual training seminar in Phoenix that teaches premises liability causes of action to plaintiff lawyers on how to prevail against landlords and property managers.

Apartment Premises Liability: A Litigation Nightmare

During a lawsuit, an apartment property is viewed under a judicial microscope, in a highly public forum. Your most confidential business records and personal financial records must be produced if so ordered by the court.

I know property owners who have literally turned their management offices upside-down looking for the critical documents that were never saved. Those documents would likely have mitigated their exposure.

As if to add insult to injury, these records produced during litigation sometimes get passed around to other plaintiff lawyers during the course of subsequent lawsuits. Not surprisingly, several property management careers have ended due to previously undisclosed indiscretions uncovered during the intense scrutiny of the manager’s backgrounds.

The process of litigation has a way of bringing out the worst flaws in property management because of the focus on the negative issues and imperfect decision-making.

Apartment Premises Liability: Defective Conditions

The largest jury awards usually involve stranger-to-stranger sexual assaults that occur inside an apartment unit. The question of access to the unit is always the focal point at issue.

Victim studies tell us that most rapists gain access through unlocked doors and windows. When a lawsuit is filed, however, the allegation often is that the door or window locking hardware was defective and allowed the rapist access.

As you can imagine, it would be difficult to defend against such a claim without having solid documentation of the actual condition of the door and door locks prior to the incident.

Apartment Premises Liability: Good Documentation is Critical

The best time to test and document the condition of the door and window locks and latches is during the unit walk-through with the incoming and outgoing residents. The leasing consultant and the new resident should test each lock and latch and document that the devices work properly and are in good condition. It’s not enough to state that all locks and latches are okay.

A better plan is to itemize the location and condition of each protected window and door opening. For example, list the condition of the sliding glass door and each bedroom window latches separately.

By modifying your existing walk-through form, you can easily document the incoming and outgoing condition of the hardware with each resident. If you supply secondary sliding door and window blocking and anti-lift devices, their presence and condition should also be noted on the form.

The form should include a resident signature certifying that they have observed you point out, demonstrate, and test each device and found them in good working order. In this way, you have evidence of two tests that the locks and latches were functioning. You should also add a line where the resident agrees to use the locking devices at all times and will report any defects immediately.

This procedure, coupled with good key control and lock maintenance, will provide your residents with adequate security in the unit and significantly reduce your exposure to lawsuits in this area.

Learn More about Premises Liability Litigation

Download the 115-page eBook written by Security Expert Chris E. McGoey

  • Security Expert’s Guide to Premises Liability Litigation
  • Evaluating Crime Foreseeability and Inadequate Security Cases

Chris McGoey has authored a tremendous practical guide about premises liability litigation for attorneys, security consultants, risk managers, landlords, law enforcement, and business operators.

“You won’t find a better book on this subject!”

If you’re a trial lawyer, you simply “Must Read This Book”

  • 115 pages 8.5 X 11″ — Instant Download (PDF) – Revised 2023.
    Copyright © 2009 – 2023 Aegis Books, Inc.

Click the Buy Now button. Pay via PayPal or Credit-Debit Cards

Instant Download  $25   –   

  • Online Orders are Secure via PayPal Server
  • Unconditional Money-Back Guarantee
    • Biography of Chris E. McGoey
    • Testimonials from a few clients
    • Speaking Engagements
    • Media Interviews
    • Premises Liability Litigation Book
    • Retain Chris as a Security Expert Witness
    • Chris McGoey Blog Article Index
    • Crime School Podcast Episode Index

    Contact Security Expert Chris E. McGoey

    Jonesborough, Tennessee

    951-461-8950

    Chris@CrimeDoctor.com

    Premises Security Expert; Premises Liability Security Expert; Service area: Eastern and southern USA, Tennessee, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, West Virginia, Missouri, Kentucky, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Georgia, Alabama, Arkansas, Mississippi, Louisiana, Florida. After 39 years of serving California, Nevada, Arizona, Washington.

    Tagged With: apartment security, premises liability

    About Chris McGoey

    My biography spans 53 years of studying, evaluating, and developing security plans worldwide. I'm a habitual skeptic, a chronic people watcher, a golf fanatic, and a relentless traveler.
    Email | Twitter

    Related Posts You May Like

    • Apartment Security Safe Housing – Should Landlords Provide Security?
    • Apartment Security Advice for Families Seeking Safe Rental Housing
    • Apartment Courtesy Officer versus Security Guard Patrol
    • Apartment Unauthorized Occupants Can Increase Crime Risk
    • Criminals Want Housing in Your Apartment Community
    • Crime Free Multihousing Program Three Phase Apartment Security Plan

    Premises Liability eBook

    Premises Liability Book

    Podcast Reviews

    • Great information and insight
      June 13, 2018 by djpoland from United States

      I have been listening to this podcast now for several months. It is one of the best sources of information concerning crime, security, and ways of making your home and business safe. Keep up the good work. Thank you for all you do to help so many people. DJ in Scottsburg, IN

    • Interesting, provocative, relevant and riveting
      July 29, 2017 by Lindapre from United States

      This is a very valuable service and I appreciate this high level of expertise to keep me knowledgeable, safe and sound. Everyone should subscribe and stay well-informed. Thanks Chris!

    • 10 reasons why burglars might choose your home
      July 28, 2017 by binwoodside from United States

      I am not one of those people who believes there is a bad guy behind every bush but Chris offers good advice that can be very useful to all of us. His tips can prevent us experiencing a home robbery due to our own carelessness. It amazes me that people use social media to advertise their absence from their homes. There are plenty of other points of carelessness Chris describes that also advertises to burglars. His voice is easy to understand and listen.

    • Educational eye-opening strategies for crime prevention
      October 22, 2015 by taylor826 from United States

      He pretty much covers the gamut of high-risk scenario from personal safety to commercial property security. He provides insights to how criminals could perceive potential victims as vulnerable. I don't own commercial property or a business, but the security best practices he outlines which mitigate potential crimes in multiple industries, also increases my awareness to avoid such businesses/locations that don't implement those policies. You don't want to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.

    • Excellent content
      July 1, 2015 by Ken Burgin from Australia

      Chris has been the ‘crime doctor’ for many businesses over the years - not much he hasn’t seen and fixed! Great to have his expertise coming to us directly through his podcast interviews. Highly recommended!

    • Crime School Radio is a Winner!
      June 18, 2015 by Liquor License Advisor from United States

      As a security expert, Chris McGoey was and continues to be a trailblazer. First, his informative website and book. Now this convenient, cutting-edge and educational podcast. Chris has an uncanny knack for knowing just what the world needs. With this show, he delivers vital information on safety and security in plain language that everyone can benefit from.

    • Helpful Content for Retail and LEO
      May 21, 2015 by StandardOfTruth from United States

      Chris is an industry expert with real world experience. It is also refreshing to hear a security podcast with crystal clear audio and presented in a professional way.

    • Fantastic! Informative and relevant.
      May 13, 2015 by isntrocketscience from United States

      I have seen Chris McGoey several times as a security expert on TV so I was curious to hear his Crime School podcast. As expected the podcast provides valuable information for keeping us safe and useful ideas for everyday life. I plan to listen to every episode. Keep 'em coming Chris.

    • Home Security Safe Room
      May 13, 2015 by TimInArizona from United States

      Outstanding! Very thorough. I would like to see police departments link to this audio as part of their crime prevention education of their citizens.

    • Great show about crime and loss prevention
      May 12, 2015 by CrimeRx from United States

      A great resource for new and veteran crime prevention practitioners. I have subscribed so I won't miss and episode.

    Chris E. McGoey CPP, CSP, ICPS, CAM
    McGoey Security Consulting
    Jonesborough, Tennessee
    951-461-8950
    Chris@CrimeDoctor.com

    Copyright © 2023 - Aegis Books, Inc and Chris E. McGoey - All Rights Reserved -

    Terms of Use  |  Disclaimer  |  Privacy Policy